Who are my Home Assistant + ZWave-JS users?
-
Had some issues with Aqara motion sensors falling off my Hubitat after a few hours. (Yes, the manufacturer is not supported on HE.) But this led me down a path to stand up HA in my docker. Which then led me down another path of getting the zwavejs2mqtt docker running and integrated. So I may be down for this.
Am I assuming that MSR will become my JS provider and I could possibly shutdown the zwavejs2mqtt docker?
-
@toggledbits Any info on what and when this is coming?
@rogero I got bogged down trying to get newer scene controllers to work, and I think I've got it now. Really nice, actually (using a Zooz ZEN32 for testing). Heck, I even got an ancient Everwave SC-7 working great, and it just wasn't reliable on Vera at all. The effort being put into Z-Wave JS really shows.
@3rdstng said in Who are my Home Assistant + ZWave-JS users?:
Am I assuming that MSR will become my JS provider and I could possibly shutdown the zwavejs2mqtt docker?
You'll either need to keep zwavejs2mqtt or install and run the zwave-js-server. I'm not doing a direct interface (i.e. library direct to serial port) just yet, but that's coming. The management tools of zwavejs2mqtt are pretty nice, so that's a good incentive to keep it.
-
@toggledbits Next you will be saying your Leviton scene controllers are working perfectly.
@rogero I've had those going good for a while on Vera, using a plugin I wrote but never published (a few people got it, though... were you one of them?). I don't expect much trouble from them on Z-WaveJS. Also testing Hank 4-button and Remotec ZRC-90.
-
Yes, I was one of the people you shared it with. It did work very well. Replaced them with the ZEN32's but at my age I cannot remember what 4 pushes of the bottom left button does, etc. Need to tape a legend to the wall. Look forward to having them running in MSR.
-
Haven't forgotten you all... I've been working furiously at putting this together, including a new build system (because I'll be doing this release on a separate track, not in latest). I'm trying to get something out this weekend for a first look.
Do any/all/none of you all use Discord?
-
@vezinpi said in Who are my Home Assistant + ZWave-JS users?:
I don't, but I could if that's the way you want to communicate.
Same
-
Just trying to gauge what people use. Doesn't seem like a path with enough support in this community, and that's fine; it's not my favorite, either.
-
OK, I just PM'd the 9 of you that stepped up. If you replied on this post but didn't get a PM from me, let me know.
Some things to know about the test...
First and most important to Docker users, it runs on a different image from the mainstream latest, so you'll need to create a new container.
For all participants, the test code is bi-directionally compatible with the mainstream latest release path, so you'll be able to move back and forth between them if you need to. I think you'll be fine staying on the zwavejs track, and it will keep pace with other development throughout. Always make a backup of your config, of course, just in case, but you should be able to use the same config freely with any current version (the non-Zwave versions will complain about the controller not being available, though, and then move along).
I have a meager variety of devices to test with (lots of devices but limited in breadth of type and manufacturer), so I expect a lot of exceptions and oddities with the various devices out there. Don't panic. We know from all of our other Z-Wave platforms that manufacturers have leeway to do things within the spec, and they take it, and that complicates onboarding devices. Everyone goes through this. We won't be an exception.
I have to say, I'm really excited about this. ZWave-JS is really nice. First and foremost, it seems completely unbothered by device errors and mesh problems; it doesn't crash, delay, or do other things that other (ahem) platforms can't seem to get right. That alone makes it worth the effort. It's got a lot of support and the developers are really active. I have high hopes.
Discussion here is fine. Seems like the easiest way to go. Remember to be as complete as possible in your descriptions of issues, including device details, logs, etc. This version will create its own
zwavejs.log, so that's a good place to start (and removes the noise of all the other subsystems).There is data collection. The form you are asked to complete in the PM declares this as well, and you are asked to agree to it. It sends me a copy of your Z-WaveJS device inventory on startup, which will help (a lot) with device support. It does not send logs; that we'll have to do as needed. Happy to answer any questions on this, of course.
-
@toggledbits Will you post a list of the devices you see in the initial survey from the nine participants? I have half my system on Vera and would move over any devices I have that are not on your list.
-
Really appreciate the effort. My Vera with all the non-migrated Z-Wave is currently not reachable (holiday home). Can't migrate the devices to HA without being there. End of March I might be there to do it. Still need to find a way to get MSR to run. There is no easy way to run it on the same hardware my HA is running on (I run HA OS on bare metal). Or have I missed a MSR addon for HA?
-
Finally got there... MSR-zwavejs installation (docker) went very well, no issues there. It was a different story with HASS. I am running an unsupported version of Home Assistant Supervised on a raspberry pi (bulleyes). I had to get rid of the zwave2mqtt addon and install it by itself (still with docker). Then I had to re-install the zwavejs integration. Home assistant documentation for zwave has a procedure to migrate the integratio to a new server without losing any devices. That helped alot.
@toggledbits, you should be seeing some data going you way. If not let me know. I will also complete my transition from vera to zwavejs in the following days. So more devices will eventually show up.
-
Can you please first answer my question? It's pretty much work what you ask.
Question: I know reactor by name. Do I need it? I have 80 zwavjes devices and a fully loaded homeassistant (+20 integrations)
@sender said in Who are my Home Assistant + ZWave-JS users?:
Can you please first answer my question? It's pretty much work what you ask.
Question: I know reactor by name. Do I need it? I have 80 zwavjes devices and a fully loaded homeassistant (+20 integrations)If you're not a current Reactor user and familiar with it, this isn't the situation in which to learn. I'll remove you from the test list.
-
I will have my first update to post later today with some fixes and a lot of new device support (thanks to those of you running so far -- lots of data, good stuff!).
-
@toggledbits Since we are at the beginning of this, should we put a header like "ZWAVE-JS" at the begining of the title for every new post related to Zwave-JS just to flag the topic? Or do we keep on going into this thread for all issues, questions, etc...?
How would you like us to proceed?