Skip to content
  • Categories
  • Recent
  • Tags
  • Popular
  • Unsolved
Collapse
Discussion Forum to share and further the development of home control and automation, independent of platforms.
  1. Home
  2. Software
  3. Multi-System Reactor
  4. What notification system is best?
[Reactor] Variables not updating correctly in latest-25201-2aa18550
therealdbT
Topic thumbnail image
Multi-System Reactor
Handling Dead Entities and Renamed Entities
PablaP
Hello all.. been a minute! I recently rebuilt my Z wave network and migrated to a new z wave stick. In order to prevent any downtime I kept my original z wave network up and ran a docker version of Z Wave JS UI with my new controller. This way I could add device by device without having any devices down. I finally moved all the devices over to my new stick today. The final step was to migrate everything from my Docker instance of Z Wave JS UI to the HA add-on of Z Wave JS UI. However during this migration some of the names didn't populate correctly which I later managed to import back into Z Wave JS UI. The issue was in Reactor it is stuck on the default names and the entities are not updating. I removed the controller from Reactor, restarted, hard refreshed, and added the controller back however the new entity names have not updated. Also it seems like the old entities from my previous instance of Z Wave JS UI are lingering and not being marked as dead (I believe a certain amount of time needs to lapse before they're marked as dead in Reactor). My goal is to basically purge all the entities for the 'ZWaveJS' controller in Reactor so it can pull all the updated entity names and only the entities that exist in Z Wave JS UI. I cannot find a quick way to do this, I know entities can be deleted one by one, but with over 100 entities this would take long I am guessing that if I added the controller with a new name in in the Reactor config it would pull the updated entities and names but I think that would break my rules since the entity IDs would change (I made sure to name all the entities the exact same as they were previously to prevent this issue).
Multi-System Reactor
Strange behavior for MQTT templates using payload and attributes
therealdbT
Topic thumbnail image
Multi-System Reactor
[MSR] reactor-mqtt-contrib package for additional MQTT templates
therealdbT
I'm slowly migrating all my stuff to MQTT under MSR, so I have a central place to integrate everything (and, in a not-so-distant future, to remove virtual devices from my Vera and leave it running zwave only). Anyway, here's my reactor-mqtt-contrib package: https://github.com/dbochicchio/reactor-mqtt-contrib Simply download yaml files (everything or just the ones you need) and you're good to go. I have mapped my most useful devices, but I'll add others soon. Feel free to ask for specific templates, since I've worked a lot in the last weeks to understand and operate them. The templates are supporting both init and query, so you have always up-to-date devices at startup, and the ability to poll them. Online status is supported as well, so you can get disconnected devices with a simple expression. Many-many thanks to @toggledbits for its dedication, support, and patience with me and my requests
Multi-System Reactor
HA 2025.9.4 Supported Yet?
CatmanV2C
Tangentially did I miss 2025.9.4 getting blessed in MSR? I've been holding off Cheers C
Multi-System Reactor
The reaction stopped working (Google Nest max playing a video)
F
Topic thumbnail image
Multi-System Reactor
Rule Set UI bug - RESOLVED
3
Topic thumbnail image
Multi-System Reactor
[Reactor] Copy&Paste of Rules
therealdbT
I don't know if I'm the only one, but managing more than one Reactor installs, the need to have some sort of copy&paste for rules has grown on me. While I understand the technical challenges, I'm wondering if a "god mode" where I could copy the raw JSON rule and paste it into another rule could be an advanced, flag only feature that could benefit power users. I know I can copy the JSON file and proceed, but I must stop Reactor and when doing maintenance, it's more clicks to do. Just an idea
Multi-System Reactor
[Reactor] Help with screne controller cycling logic
therealdbT
I’ve added a couple of Shelly Wave i4 as scene controllers and I’m planning to add more, since I can just use standard buttons instead of battery-powered scene controllers, which also looks better aesthetically. That said, I’m struggling to figure out how to write a simple rule that cycles between states every time I press a button. Example: Light 1 ON → OFF, then Light 2 ON → OFF. The part I can’t get right is handling the case where Light 1 or Light 2 might already be ON independently of the rule. Maybe it’s just too much sun and relaxation clouding my brain, but any hint would be appreciated.
Multi-System Reactor
Stop the MSR by an external switch on Hubitat.
wmarcolinW
Use case: When performing home maintenance, such as air conditioning, I want all rules involving air conditioning to be disabled. To do this, to day, I have a virtual switch that I placed within all rules involving air conditioning, meaning that if I turn it off, none of them work. Then another situation: the water pump system and garden irrigation, another switch. In short, I had to create several virtual switches in Hubitat to disable rules in MSR. Unfortunately, however, I was unable to cover all scenarios, so I wondered if it would be possible for MSR to support a virtual MSR switch, which, when configured in the reactor settings, would function as a general on/off switch for MSR. If it is configured and turned off, the entire rules and actions in MSR stops working, except for the status change reading process, specifically for this switch, which, when turned on, would restart the MSR. Would it be possible to do something like this? Any recommendations from the experts?
Multi-System Reactor
Expose MSR entities
CatmanV2C
Probably a really dumb question. Currently I am using the owntracks_sensor for tracking phones being in region in MSR and it works great. Digging around with Home Assistant and toying with some dashboards, is there any way of exposing that sensor to HA trivially? I could set MSR to trip a virtual switch in OpenLuup which can then be exposed to HA (with all my other Vera devices) but that feels a bit in-elegant if I can do it directly. Any thoughts? Apologies if the ask is not clear/ TIA C
Multi-System Reactor
Comment in Globa Expressions
Tom_DT
I have several Global Expressions that are set by a rule so the definition area is blank. I'd like to add a comment in this area that explains what is setting the value. Commenting in this area breaks the remote setting. Any way to document what is setting the GE?
Multi-System Reactor
Unofficial thread for compatibility
tunnusT
As there are statements about compatibility for home assistant versions in MSR new version announcements (e.g. "HassController: Bless Hass to 2025.7.3"), I thought it would be good idea to track other controllers as well. As an example, I can confirm that build "latest-25208-c53e8513" works with Hubitat Elevation C-8 platform version 2.4.2.134 using Maker API. Updates: (the latest versions first in the list) OK: build "latest-25264-2fbe9217" with Hubitat C-8 platform v. 2.4.3.123
Multi-System Reactor
Gradually turn on lights.
Tom_DT
I have several lights that I would like to turn on very gradually over 15 or 20 seconds. from 0 to .25 in .01 increments. I have tried a few things that came nowhere near working, so here I am.
Multi-System Reactor
Reactor (Multi-System/Multi-Hub) Announcements
toggledbitsT
Build 21228 has been released. Docker images available from DockerHub as usual, and bare-metal packages here. Home Assistant up to version 2021.8.6 supported; the online version of the manual will now state the current supported versions; Fix an error in OWMWeatherController that could cause it to stop updating; Unify the approach to entity filtering on all hub interface classes (controllers); this works for device entities only; it may be extended to other entities later; Improve error detail in messages for EzloController during auth phase; Add isRuleSet() and isRuleEnabled() functions to expressions extensions; Implement set action for lock and passage capabilities (makes them more easily scriptable in some cases); Fix a place in the UI where 24-hour time was not being displayed.
Multi-System Reactor
Can't customize home page
G
I foolishly let my system wipe all cookies this morning and with it my settings for my MSR home page. Once logged back in I can no longer remove errant panes nor is the + available to add new ones. Brave Browser v1.80.122 (Jul 16, 2025) What have I done?! Will check other browsers on my M1. UPDATE: Safari exhibits same behaviour. I've tried both sans last-four public key entry and with - no change.
Multi-System Reactor
Error After Upgrade
T
Topic thumbnail image
Multi-System Reactor
Reset attribute value of entity in event handler
R
Topic thumbnail image
Multi-System Reactor
Need help figuring out how to delay a reset on reaction
T
Topic thumbnail image
Multi-System Reactor
Way to search for rules (rule state) in other rules
T
@toggledbits, not sure if this is a feature request or I'm using the search tool wrong. You have a "Search for rule" in the Rules Set tab in MSR. It works nicely to find a rule and bring up said rule, but can it/could it be used for as a "where used?" global search? For instance, I have a fairly large set of rules, divided up into 10 different rulesets. There's easily a hundred individual rules, and many of the rules have Rule State triggers, which of course refer to other rules. Amongst my troubleshooting today, I came across what may have been a duplicate or troubleshooting attempt, but I can't tell if it's actually used as a Rule State in another rule without opening each rule that I suspect it may be a part of. Thanks.
Multi-System Reactor

What notification system is best?

Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Multi-System Reactor
16 Posts 9 Posters 1.2k Views 9 Watching
  • Oldest to Newest
  • Newest to Oldest
  • Most Votes
Reply
  • Reply as topic
Log in to reply
This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
  • A Andr

    Hi everyone

    I'm about to set up notifications from MSR and would like input on what works best.
    Quick and reliable delivery to Android devices is the goal.

    (Tried to set up pushover last night, but probably missed something because it doesn't work. Succeed thru homeassistant, but not with MSR.)

    Is pushover worth its money?
    what do you use and why?

    Greatly appreciate your thoughts 🙂

    tunnusT Offline
    tunnusT Offline
    tunnus
    wrote on last edited by
    #3

    @andr Telegram. No regrets

    Using MSR on Docker (Synology NAS), having InfluxDB, Grafana & Home Assistant, Hubitat C-8, Zigbee2MQTT

    1 Reply Last reply
    1
    • therealdbT Offline
      therealdbT Offline
      therealdb
      wrote on last edited by
      #4

      Telegram here as well. I’ve deeply customized with a bot, pushing videos from my cams and accepting commands with wizards as well.

      --
      On a mission to automate everything.

      My MS Reactor contrib
      My Luup Plug-ins

      A 1 Reply Last reply
      0
      • therealdbT therealdb

        Telegram here as well. I’ve deeply customized with a bot, pushing videos from my cams and accepting commands with wizards as well.

        A Offline
        A Offline
        Andr
        wrote on last edited by
        #5

        @therealdb said in What notification system is best?:

        Telegram here as well. I’ve deeply customized with a bot, pushing videos from my cams and accepting commands with wizards as well.

        Do you mean a "chatbot" that you can respond to? That sounds cool, could you give som example of what you use it for?

        Right now I struggle with Pushover. Can't find out why it doesn't work.😖
        From reactor.log:
        default:null Module NotifyPushover v21195
        Engine:ERR Engine#1 reaction re-kud4t99t step 0 notification (Pushover) failed: Error: Pushover user and token could not be determined

        From notification.yaml

          # Pushover
          Pushover:
            profiles:
              default:
                # description - A friendly description of this profile (for menus)
                description: Andre
                #
                # user - (required) user key from Pushover. Refer to the Reactor docs for
                #        the Notify action for info on how to get your user key.
                #user: u4cXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXtkv1d
                #
                # token - (required) token from Pushover site. Again, see the Reactor docs
                #         for info. This is the default token used for this profile if a
                #         token is not specified in the notification parameters.
                #token: amwXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXn7if
                #
                # default_device - (optional) name of the default device to receive not-
                #                  ifications. You can leave this blank, and the default
                #                  device will be whatever the Pushover API determines. If
                #                  set here, it's the default for this profile, when no
                #                  device is specified in the Notify action itself.
                #default_device: ""
                #
                # default_title - (optional) default notification title to use for this
                #                 profile. It will be used when no title is specified in
                #                 the Notify action. If no title is specified at all, the
                #                 system default title "Reactor" will be used.
                #default_title: "Reactor Notification"
        

        The Reaction
        568b81e0-3ad6-44b8-bd89-3ff26628429a-image.png

        I have tried to put user id & token between citation marks " "
        Same user id & token work from pushover site and when sending notification from Homeassistant.

        CrilleC 1 Reply Last reply
        0
        • A Andr

          @therealdb said in What notification system is best?:

          Telegram here as well. I’ve deeply customized with a bot, pushing videos from my cams and accepting commands with wizards as well.

          Do you mean a "chatbot" that you can respond to? That sounds cool, could you give som example of what you use it for?

          Right now I struggle with Pushover. Can't find out why it doesn't work.😖
          From reactor.log:
          default:null Module NotifyPushover v21195
          Engine:ERR Engine#1 reaction re-kud4t99t step 0 notification (Pushover) failed: Error: Pushover user and token could not be determined

          From notification.yaml

            # Pushover
            Pushover:
              profiles:
                default:
                  # description - A friendly description of this profile (for menus)
                  description: Andre
                  #
                  # user - (required) user key from Pushover. Refer to the Reactor docs for
                  #        the Notify action for info on how to get your user key.
                  #user: u4cXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXtkv1d
                  #
                  # token - (required) token from Pushover site. Again, see the Reactor docs
                  #         for info. This is the default token used for this profile if a
                  #         token is not specified in the notification parameters.
                  #token: amwXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXn7if
                  #
                  # default_device - (optional) name of the default device to receive not-
                  #                  ifications. You can leave this blank, and the default
                  #                  device will be whatever the Pushover API determines. If
                  #                  set here, it's the default for this profile, when no
                  #                  device is specified in the Notify action itself.
                  #default_device: ""
                  #
                  # default_title - (optional) default notification title to use for this
                  #                 profile. It will be used when no title is specified in
                  #                 the Notify action. If no title is specified at all, the
                  #                 system default title "Reactor" will be used.
                  #default_title: "Reactor Notification"
          

          The Reaction
          568b81e0-3ad6-44b8-bd89-3ff26628429a-image.png

          I have tried to put user id & token between citation marks " "
          Same user id & token work from pushover site and when sending notification from Homeassistant.

          CrilleC Offline
          CrilleC Offline
          Crille
          wrote on last edited by
          #6

          @andr Remove the “#” in front of user id and token

          A 1 Reply Last reply
          1
          • CrilleC Crille

            @andr Remove the “#” in front of user id and token

            A Offline
            A Offline
            Andr
            wrote on last edited by
            #7

            @crille
            THANKS!!🙏🏼

            Now Pushover works.
            Time to take a look at that Telegrambot 🙂

            1 Reply Last reply
            1
            • CrilleC Offline
              CrilleC Offline
              Crille
              wrote on last edited by Crille
              #8

              I use pushover for all my notifications and have been doing so since 2013. A really good and stable service. Started using it before it became a subscription service so was upgraded to “free for life” when they introduced that.
              Telegram is looking very interesting though 🙂

              Edit: I see it’s a one-time fee per platform now, not a subscription.

              A 1 Reply Last reply
              0
              • CrilleC Crille

                I use pushover for all my notifications and have been doing so since 2013. A really good and stable service. Started using it before it became a subscription service so was upgraded to “free for life” when they introduced that.
                Telegram is looking very interesting though 🙂

                Edit: I see it’s a one-time fee per platform now, not a subscription.

                A Offline
                A Offline
                Andr
                wrote on last edited by
                #9

                @crille
                Yes, 5usd per platform. Not much to discuss if it is a good service.
                Will use the 30-day trial period for now to test it.

                But the telegram bot seems intresting, I got it up and running but i dont think i can manage to make good use of it.
                Me: Hey bot, heat up my car so its ready 07:45
                Bot: After consulting with MSR i found the outside temperature is -5 degrees, so I start the heater at 07:00.

                Thanks everyone for your thoughts, very helpful!

                tunnusT 1 Reply Last reply
                0
                • wmarcolinW Offline
                  wmarcolinW Offline
                  wmarcolin
                  wrote on last edited by
                  #10

                  Telegram 🙂

                  1 Reply Last reply
                  0
                  • A Andr

                    @crille
                    Yes, 5usd per platform. Not much to discuss if it is a good service.
                    Will use the 30-day trial period for now to test it.

                    But the telegram bot seems intresting, I got it up and running but i dont think i can manage to make good use of it.
                    Me: Hey bot, heat up my car so its ready 07:45
                    Bot: After consulting with MSR i found the outside temperature is -5 degrees, so I start the heater at 07:00.

                    Thanks everyone for your thoughts, very helpful!

                    tunnusT Offline
                    tunnusT Offline
                    tunnus
                    wrote on last edited by
                    #11

                    @andr interactive bot might be a bit too much for starters, but Telegram is excellent in providing different status messages set up in MSR

                    Using MSR on Docker (Synology NAS), having InfluxDB, Grafana & Home Assistant, Hubitat C-8, Zigbee2MQTT

                    1 Reply Last reply
                    0
                    • therealdbT Offline
                      therealdbT Offline
                      therealdb
                      wrote on last edited by
                      #12

                      The chat bot is used to control lights and run scenes, if necessary. I’m still on my Vera but it’s decoupled, so this is the only way to interact when outside the house.

                      I’ve also integrated my ECOVAC deebots, and opensprinkler. But we’re mainly using it to open doors and garage doors, since everything else is automated and we rarely mess with this stuff. But it was fun. It’s not parsing natural language, but it’s doable (part of my job is dedicated to this stuff, so this was a sort of research project for me back in the days).

                      --
                      On a mission to automate everything.

                      My MS Reactor contrib
                      My Luup Plug-ins

                      PablaP 1 Reply Last reply
                      0
                      • G Offline
                        G Offline
                        gwp1
                        wrote on last edited by
                        #13

                        Dipped my toe with Prowl, saw Pushover and haven't looked back. I like the ability to "personalize" the notifications both textually and audibly.

                        *Hubitat C-7 2.4.3.123
                        *Proxmox VE v8, Beelink MiniPC 12GBs, SSD

                        *HASS 2025.9.4
                        w/ ZST10-700 fw 7.18.3

                        *Prod MSR in docker/portainer
                        MSR: latest-25264-2fbe9217
                        MQTTController: 25139
                        ZWave Controller: 25139

                        1 Reply Last reply
                        0
                        • CatmanV2C Offline
                          CatmanV2C Offline
                          CatmanV2
                          wrote on last edited by
                          #14

                          Telegram. Zero maintenance.

                          C

                          The Ex-Vera abuser know as CatmanV2.....

                          1 Reply Last reply
                          0
                          • therealdbT therealdb

                            The chat bot is used to control lights and run scenes, if necessary. I’m still on my Vera but it’s decoupled, so this is the only way to interact when outside the house.

                            I’ve also integrated my ECOVAC deebots, and opensprinkler. But we’re mainly using it to open doors and garage doors, since everything else is automated and we rarely mess with this stuff. But it was fun. It’s not parsing natural language, but it’s doable (part of my job is dedicated to this stuff, so this was a sort of research project for me back in the days).

                            PablaP Offline
                            PablaP Offline
                            Pabla
                            wrote on last edited by
                            #15

                            @therealdb said in What notification system is best?:

                            The chat bot is used to control lights and run scenes, if necessary. I’m still on my Vera but it’s decoupled, so this is the only way to interact when outside the house.

                            I’ve also integrated my ECOVAC deebots, and opensprinkler. But we’re mainly using it to open doors and garage doors, since everything else is automated and we rarely mess with this stuff. But it was fun. It’s not parsing natural language, but it’s doable (part of my job is dedicated to this stuff, so this was a sort of research project for me back in the days).

                            This chat bot sounds interesting, if I am reading this correctly in the Telegram group chat you can basically tell the bot to do certain things that are preconfigured?

                            therealdbT 1 Reply Last reply
                            0
                            • PablaP Pabla

                              @therealdb said in What notification system is best?:

                              The chat bot is used to control lights and run scenes, if necessary. I’m still on my Vera but it’s decoupled, so this is the only way to interact when outside the house.

                              I’ve also integrated my ECOVAC deebots, and opensprinkler. But we’re mainly using it to open doors and garage doors, since everything else is automated and we rarely mess with this stuff. But it was fun. It’s not parsing natural language, but it’s doable (part of my job is dedicated to this stuff, so this was a sort of research project for me back in the days).

                              This chat bot sounds interesting, if I am reading this correctly in the Telegram group chat you can basically tell the bot to do certain things that are preconfigured?

                              therealdbT Offline
                              therealdbT Offline
                              therealdb
                              wrote on last edited by
                              #16

                              @pabla yep. It’s not a product, but very specific to my needs, so I’ve not released it. I’ll see if I could post some screenshot to be of inspiration to others. AFAIK home assistant has something like this built in (or, maybe, it’s open hab)

                              --
                              On a mission to automate everything.

                              My MS Reactor contrib
                              My Luup Plug-ins

                              1 Reply Last reply
                              1
                              • toggledbitsT toggledbits locked this topic on
                              Reply
                              • Reply as topic
                              Log in to reply
                              • Oldest to Newest
                              • Newest to Oldest
                              • Most Votes


                              Recent Topics

                              • Caution: zwave-js-ui docker 11.4.0 is broken
                                toggledbitsT
                                toggledbits
                                0
                                2
                                36

                              • [Reactor] Variables not updating correctly in latest-25201-2aa18550
                                toggledbitsT
                                toggledbits
                                0
                                68
                                4.9k

                              • Shelly Wall Display XL
                                therealdbT
                                therealdb
                                2
                                6
                                95

                              • Handling Dead Entities and Renamed Entities
                                PablaP
                                Pabla
                                0
                                5
                                87

                              • Strange behavior for MQTT templates using payload and attributes
                                toggledbitsT
                                toggledbits
                                0
                                6
                                137

                              • [MSR] reactor-mqtt-contrib package for additional MQTT templates
                                therealdbT
                                therealdb
                                1
                                46
                                8.3k

                              • HA 2025.9.4 Supported Yet?
                                toggledbitsT
                                toggledbits
                                0
                                2
                                91

                              • The reaction stopped working (Google Nest max playing a video)
                                toggledbitsT
                                toggledbits
                                0
                                7
                                359

                              • Rule Set UI bug - RESOLVED
                                toggledbitsT
                                toggledbits
                                1
                                2
                                234

                              • [Reactor] Copy&Paste of Rules
                                therealdbT
                                therealdb
                                0
                                1
                                301

                              • [Reactor] Help with screne controller cycling logic
                                toggledbitsT
                                toggledbits
                                0
                                5
                                404

                              • Stop the MSR by an external switch on Hubitat.
                                Tom_DT
                                Tom_D
                                0
                                6
                                740
                              Powered by NodeBB | Contributors
                              Hosted freely by 10RUPTiV - Solutions Technologiques | Contact us
                              • Login

                              • Don't have an account? Register

                              • Login or register to search.
                              • First post
                                Last post
                              0
                              • Categories
                              • Recent
                              • Tags
                              • Popular
                              • Unsolved