Skip to content
  • Categories
  • Recent
  • Tags
  • Popular
  • Unsolved
Collapse
Discussion Forum to share and further the development of home control and automation, independent of platforms.
  1. Home
  2. Hardware
  3. Zigbee
  4. Any thoughts on which is better
Any thoughts on which is better
CatmanV2C
Obviously a quiet forum, but perhaps it's time I'm looking at rolling Zigbee into my system, in large part for the Aqara FP300 presence sensors which seem to finally provide a solution to if the wasp is actually in the box. My current set up is as follows: One Debian VM on Synology NAS running: Z-wave Server Open Luup Multi system reactor HA bridge Mosquito MQQT broker This machine has a UZB Z-wave stick connected via the USB port on the NAS Another HAOS VM on the same NAS running HAOS I've got some older Z-wave stuff that I keep around until it fails. I have some Tuya stuff integrated in HA My thought was to get either a SMLIGHT SLZB-06M or an Aqara Hub M2 Integrate them via Zigbee2MQQT (running on the Debian machine) and then expose them in HA so I can continue to automate in MSR. Thoughts on which of those devices wold be preferable long term. Both are POE capable which is good. It also appears I could add a USB dongle to the NAS and expose it to the HAOS machine. Any thoughts from the assembled experts here? TIA C
Zigbee
High temperature sensor for Zigbee
R
I have an oven that I need to manage the temperature of, keeping it in the neighborhood of 600° C (1100° F). I have not been able to find a Zigbee-enabled solution to measure temps that high. Does anyone know if such a thing exists? If not, any ideas for how to roll a custom solution that I could integrate into a Sonoff ihost controller? I have no trouble finding high temperature probes, but none of them interface with my automation stack.
Zigbee
Hue Tap Dial compatible online switch
F
I have got mainly hue bulbs around the house, apart from a couple of places where it wasn't practical or pretty enough. In those cases I put in sonoff in line switches so I can control them remotely. But now I'm wanting to further upgrade by replacing most of my light switches with Hue Tap dials (and add some fittings in where I tend to not want lots of light, but will need it some time). Then I can easily switch between different profiles and have guests do the same. Does anyone know if I can get a replacement for the sonoffs that can be recognised in Hue so that I can control it with the Tap Dials? Or alternatively any good alternatives to replacing the light switches with smart controllers? Thanks
Zigbee
Zigbee Smart bridge
M
I'm looking for a zigbee smart bridge recommendation. I need something I can hide in the ceiling as want to use for downlights. I don't want a pairing button, I'm looking for another idea as don't want to pull out the ceiling to re-pair. Must work with Amazon hub, as I don't want to use manufacturers hub. Any recommendations? Thanks,
Zigbee
Silvercrest (LiDL) WiFi plug
M
Does anyone know if it is possible to use my old Silvercrest SWS-A1 plugs with the Link2Home app or the TCP (Aldi) app?
Zigbee
Sonoff zbmini-l and philips hue
L
Hello! I have recently begun making my home smarter, and I've run into some trouble while trying to get my Sonoff zbmini-l, which is connected to my Philips Hue bridge, to work properly. I am able to control it individually, but not through scenes or with the Google Home app. Has anyone else encountered this problem and know of a fix? Additionally, I have another Zigbee bridge, but I am unable to find the Sonoff device on it. Thank you in advance for your help! PS: I am very new to this.
Zigbee
Sudden offset in temperature reading
PerHP
Topic thumbnail image
Zigbee
Deconz
rafale77R
After researching a number of various Zigbee solutions, I have come to the conclusion that Deconz with a ConbeeII is probably the best one available, covering the two HA1.2 stacks and ZLL stacks with the widest compatibility range, even better than the ZHA or Zigbee2MQTT components of Home Assistant, and also the best maintained with regurlar firmware updates. It is really an equivalent to z-way but for zigbee. It has a rest API so I am dreaming awake of a bridge for openLuup here... https://dresden-elektronik.github.io/deconz-rest-doc/ Could be a good project? I may get one to play with... It could potentially enable unifying the hue devices into one network.
Zigbee
2.4Ghz band Zigbee, WIFI, BT, Microwave, Cordless Phones Interferences. What Zigbee channel to pick?
rafale77R
Kicking off this section with a quick write up on Zigbee 2.4GHz channel utilization. Zigbee has become a very popular protocol over the past few years mostly due to its low power consumption, low chip cost (not being proprietary like z-wave was) and ease of inclusion. It does come with a couple of downsides however ranging from single controller topography (aka single PAN coordinator) to what the title says: It uses the 2.4GHz (ISM) band which is possibly ultra saturated by other wireless protocols and even a variety of other more or less proprietary zigbee stacks. (i.e philips hue, Ikea Tradfi, Xiaomi, Plantlink etc...) It is therefore important to make sure they don't interfere with one another. This is a good article showing the correspondence between Zigbee and WIFI. https://support.metageek.com/hc/en-us/articles/203845040-ZigBee-and-WiFi-Coexistence Interferences lead to range reduction, dropped packets, more retries and lags. I have a 2.4GHz spectrum analyzer I can post some results from. I read through the zigbee alliance presentation claiming low interference but my experience demonstrates quite the opposite. When I was using SonosNET and Hue at the same time on neighboring channels, playing SONOS would kill the philips hue network.
Zigbee

Any thoughts on which is better

Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Zigbee
1 Posts 1 Posters 3 Views 1 Watching
  • Oldest to Newest
  • Newest to Oldest
  • Most Votes
Reply
  • Reply as topic
Log in to reply
This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
  • CatmanV2C Offline
    CatmanV2C Offline
    CatmanV2
    wrote last edited by CatmanV2
    #1

    Obviously a quiet forum, but perhaps it's time 🙂

    I'm looking at rolling Zigbee into my system, in large part for the Aqara FP300 presence sensors which seem to finally provide a solution to if the wasp is actually in the box.

    My current set up is as follows:

    One Debian VM on Synology NAS running:
    Z-wave Server
    Open Luup
    Multi system reactor
    HA bridge
    Mosquito MQQT broker
    This machine has a UZB Z-wave stick connected via the USB port on the NAS

    Another HAOS VM on the same NAS running HAOS

    I've got some older Z-wave stuff that I keep around until it fails.
    I have some Tuya stuff integrated in HA

    My thought was to get either a SMLIGHT SLZB-06M
    or an Aqara Hub M2

    Integrate them via Zigbee2MQQT (running on the Debian machine) and then expose them in HA so I can continue to automate in MSR.

    Thoughts on which of those devices wold be preferable long term. Both are POE capable which is good. It also appears I could add a USB dongle to the NAS and expose it to the HAOS machine.

    Any thoughts from the assembled experts here? TIA

    C

    The Ex-Vera abuser know as CatmanV2.....

    1 Reply Last reply
    0
    Reply
    • Reply as topic
    Log in to reply
    • Oldest to Newest
    • Newest to Oldest
    • Most Votes


    Recent Topics

    • Oh the joy of pairing
      CatmanV2C
      CatmanV2
      0
      1
      4

    • HDMI oddness
      CatmanV2C
      CatmanV2
      0
      1
      6

    • Any thoughts on which is better
      CatmanV2C
      CatmanV2
      0
      1
      3

    • Reactor Loading Screen Safari
      CatmanV2C
      CatmanV2
      0
      3
      17

    • Constraints states visually do not match actual
      toggledbitsT
      toggledbits
      0
      2
      9

    • Home Assistant Connect ZWA-2 & ZBT-2
      therealdbT
      therealdb
      4
      14
      506

    • [MSR] Feature request: For Each action on arrays/groups
      therealdbT
      therealdb
      0
      7
      169

    • [Solved] Error: Command timeout
      toggledbitsT
      toggledbits
      0
      10
      420

    • Issue with MSR UI becoming unresponsive
      S
      sethlampman
      0
      7
      167

    • Date/time condition
      tunnusT
      tunnus
      0
      3
      123

    • Is there a way to turn this section (image in post) off?
      toggledbitsT
      toggledbits
      0
      1
      84
    Powered by NodeBB | Contributors
    Hosted freely by 10RUPTiV - Solutions Technologiques | Contact us
    • Login

    • Don't have an account? Register

    • Login or register to search.
    • First post
      Last post
    0
    • Categories
    • Recent
    • Tags
    • Popular
    • Unsolved