Skip to content
  • Categories
  • Recent
  • Tags
  • Popular
  • Unsolved
Collapse
Discussion Forum to share and further the development of home control and automation, independent of platforms.
  1. Home
  2. Software
  3. Multi-System Reactor
  4. Pushover duplicate messages.
Organizing/ structuring rule sets and rules
R

Hi guys,

Just wondering how you guys organize your rule sets and rules. I wish I had an extra layer to have some more granularity, but my feature request was not popular.

Maybe there are better ways to organize my rule sets.

I use the rule sets now primarily for rooms. So a rule set per room. But maybe grouping by functionality works better. Any examples/ suggestions would be appreciated.

Multi-System Reactor about 4 hours ago
Moving MSR from a QNAP container to RP 5 - some issues
T

I have installed MSR on a RP5 bare metal and then copied the config and store files. Everything seems to be on the RP5 but I am missing all global expression and I don't see the controller time.

Screenshot 2025-04-06 201446.png

My browser is Microsoft Edge Version 135.0.3179.54 (Official build) (64-bit)

I have probably done something stupid or missed a step but I am stuck.

Thanks for any help.

Multi-System Reactor 3 days ago
Widget deletion does not work and landing page (status) is empy
M

Hi,
It seems that the widget deletion does not work. I tried to drag the widget to the left (as explained in here https://smarthome.community/topic/1071/deleting-widgets?_=1744037333660)
but it does not delete it. Anyone else experiencing the same problem?

Also the landing page after login is empty and seems be have some JS issues on the dev console:

Screenshot from 2025-04-07 18-06-19.png

fd7f0424-debb-49d3-86d8-9a3b09ad3868-image.png

Using dockerized version of Reactor (Multi-hub) latest-25082-3c348de6 on Chromium 135.0.7049.52 (Official Build) snap (64-bit)

br,
mgvra

Multi-System Reactor 3 days ago
Need help reducing false positive notifications
T

Good day all,
I have an notification set up for my washing machine to let me know when it's complete. I have a templete sensor set up in HAAS to let me know if it's Washing, in Standby, or off, based upon the power consumption (Shelly 1PM on outlets)

- name: "Washing Machine" state: > {% if states("sensor.washer_switch_0_power")|float == 0 %} Off {% elif states("sensor.washer_switch_0_power")|float <= 2.9 %} Standby {% else %} Washing {% endif %} icon: > {% if states("sensor.washer_switch_0_power") == "off" %} mdi:washing-machine-alert {% elif states("sensor.washer_switch_0_power")|float <= 2.9 %} mdi:washing-machine-off {% else %} mdi:washing-machine {% endif %} minutes: 2

The MSR code is relatively simple. I have a built in false positive attribute for if MSR gets rebooted, because I would suddenly get tons of notifications when I upgraded MSR.

6774565a-06cc-443f-99c1-e71301b33d83-image.png

What I'm trying to introduce, is a way to verify that I just didn't bump the knob on the washing machine when transferring loads from the washer to the dryer, which turns on the display and brings the power above the Standby threshold.

The power goes up to 3.7W for about 4 minutes if the selector knob is bumped/turned.

What would the best way to do this be? I have most of my MSR code set up for a couple of years now, and my coding logic is struggling a bit.

I think I need a power threshold to be substained for a minimum time period (say 2 or 3 minutes, above 10W), before the other triggers can act. What would the best way to do that be?

Running: latest-25082-3c348de6
Fedora 41 Server
HAAS:
Core
2025.3.4
Supervisor
2025.03.4
Operating System
15.1
Frontend
20250306.0

Multi-System Reactor 4 days ago
Reactor (Multi-System/Multi-Hub) Announcements
T

Build 21228 has been released. Docker images available from DockerHub as usual, and bare-metal packages here.

Home Assistant up to version 2021.8.6 supported; the online version of the manual will now state the current supported versions; Fix an error in OWMWeatherController that could cause it to stop updating; Unify the approach to entity filtering on all hub interface classes (controllers); this works for device entities only; it may be extended to other entities later; Improve error detail in messages for EzloController during auth phase; Add isRuleSet() and isRuleEnabled() functions to expressions extensions; Implement set action for lock and passage capabilities (makes them more easily scriptable in some cases); Fix a place in the UI where 24-hour time was not being displayed.
Multi-System Reactor 5 days ago
Deleting widgets
tunnusT

Hopefully a trivial question, but how do you delete widgets in a status page? Using build 22266

Multi-System Reactor 5 days ago
MQTT configuration question
tunnusT

I have the following yaml configuration in local_mqtt_devices file

x_mqtt_device: set_speed: arguments: speed: type: str topic: "command/%friendly_name%" payload: type: json expr: '{ "fan": parameters.speed }'

While this works fine, I'm wondering how this could be changed to "fixed" parameters, as in this case "fan" only accepts "A", "Q" or a numeric value of 1-5?

Multi-System Reactor 9 days ago
System Configuration Check - time is offset
F

Hi!

I get this message when I'm on the status tab:

System Configuration Check
The time on this system and on the Reactor host are significantly different. This may be due to incorrect system configuration on either or both. Please check the configuration of both systems. The host reports 2025-04-01T15:29:29.252Z; browser reports 2025-04-01T15:29:40.528Z; difference 11.276 seconds.

I have MSR installed as a docker on my Home Assistant Blue / Hardkernel ODROID-N2/N2+. MSR version is latest-25082-3c348de6.
HA versions are:
Core 2025.3.4
Supervisor 2025.03.4
Operating System 15.1

I have restarted HA as well as MSR multiple times. This message didn´t show two weeks ago. Don´t know if it have anything to do with the latest MSR version.
Do anyone know what I can try?
Thanks in advance!
Let's Be Careful Out There (Hill Street reference...) 🙂
/Fanan

Multi-System Reactor 10 days ago
Programmatically capture HTTP Request action status code or error
therealdbT

I have a very strange situation, where if InfluxDB restarts, other containers may fail when restarting at the same time (under not easy to understand circumstances), and InfluxDB remains unreachable (and these containers crashes). I need to reboot these containers in an exact order, after rebooting InfluxDB.

While I understand what's going on, I need a way to reliable determine that InfluxDB is not reachable and these containers are not reachable, in order to identify this situation and manually check what's going on - and, maybe, in the future, automatically restart them if needed.

So, I was looking at HTTP Request action, but I need to capture the HTTP response code, instead of the response (becase if ping is OK, InfluxDB will reply with a 204), and, potentially, a way to programmatically detect that it's failing to get the response.

While I could write a custom HTTP controller for this or a custom HTTP virtual device, I was wondering if this is somewhat on you roadmap @toggledbits

Thanks!

Multi-System Reactor 12 days ago
ZwaveJSUI - RGBWW BULB - Warm/Cold White interfered with RGB settings - Bulb doesn't change color if in WarmWhite state.
N

Hi ,
I'm on
-Reactor (Multi-hub) latest-25067-62e21a2d
-Docker on Synology NAS
-ZWaveJSUI 9.31.0.6c80945

Problem with ZwaveJSUI:
When I try to change color to a bulb RGBWW, it doesn't change to the RGB color and the bulb remains warm or cold white.
I tryed with Zipato RGBW Bulb V2 RGBWE2, Hank Bulb HKZW-RGB01, Aentec 6 A-ZWA002, so seems that it happens with all RGBWW bulb with reactor/zwavejsui.

I'm using from reator the entity action: "rgb_color.set" and "rgb_color.set_rgb".
After I send the reactor command, It changes in zwavejsui the rgb settings but doesn't put the white channel to "0", so the prevalent channel remains warm/cold White and the bulb doesn't change into the rgb color.

This is the status of the bulb in zwavejsui after "rgb_color.set" (235,33,33,) and the bulb is still warmWhite.

x_zwave_values.Color_Switch_currentColor={"warmWhite":204,"coldWhite":0,"red":235,"green":33,"blue":33}

The "cold white" and "warm white" settings interfer with the rgb color settings.

Reactor can change bulb colors with rgb_color set — (value, ui8, 0x000000 to 0xffffff) or rgb_color set_rgb — (red, green, blue, all ui1, 0 to 255) but if warm or cold white
are not to "0", zwavejsui doesn't change them and I can't find a way to change into rgb or from rgb back to warm white.

So if I use from reactor: rgb_color set_rgb — (235,33,33) in zwavejsui I have

x_zwave_values.Color_Switch_targetColor={"red":235,"green":33,"blue":33} 14/03/2025, 16:43:57 - value updated Arg 0: └─commandClassName: Color Switch └─commandClass: 51 └─property: targetColor └─endpoint: 0 └─newValue └──red: 235 └──green: 33 └──blue: 33 └─prevValue └──red: 235 └──green: 33 └──blue: 33 └─propertyName: targetColor 14/03/2025, 16:43:57 - value updated Arg 0: └─commandClassName: Color Switch └─commandClass: 51 └─property: currentColor └─endpoint: 0 └─newValue └──warmWhite: 204 └──coldWhite: 0 └──red: 235 └──green: 33 └──blue: 33 └─prevValue └──warmWhite: 204 └──coldWhite: 0 └──red: 235 └──green: 33 └──blue: 33 └─propertyName: currentColor

In zwavejsui, the bulb changes rgb set but warm White remains to "204" and the bulb remais on warm White channel bacause is prevalent on rgb set.

x_zwave_values.Color_Switch_currentColor_0=204 x_zwave_values.Color_Switch_currentColor_1=0 x_zwave_values.Color_Switch_currentColor_2=235 x_zwave_values.Color_Switch_currentColor_3=33 x_zwave_values.Color_Switch_currentColor_4=33

Is it possible to targetColor also for "warmWhite" and "coldWhite" and have something similar to this?

x_zwave_values.Color_Switch_targetColor={"warmWhite":0,"coldWhite":0,"red":235,"green":33,"blue":33}

Thanks in advance.

Multi-System Reactor 13 days ago
Problem with simultaneous notifications.
T

Good day all,
I have a reaction set up, that I use for both troubleshooting and changing home modes when one of my family members either arrive or are leaving. I use the companion app for HAAS on our iPhones, and HAAS reports if the person associated with the iPhone enters or leaves the geofenced area around my home. I'm sure most MSR and HAAS users are familiar with this.

I use this rule set mainly as a condition for other rules, however, as part of troubleshooting, a notification is sent through HAAS to the companion app when the rule becomes true. The problem is that I'm getting notifications now for both arriving and departing simultaneously.

96b3f7db-ba09-499e-a78c-86903b603857-image.png

36903cdd-a87f-473b-82ef-af9ef96d3c44-image.png It used to work fine as intended. I'm not sure exactly when it changed, but now I'm getting two notifications when either of these conditions change.

Any idea what could be happening?

Edit:
Running: latest-25082-3c348de6, bare-metal Linux
ZWaveJSControllerr [0.1.25082]

Multi-System Reactor 13 days ago
Problem after upgrading to 25067
R

MSR had been running fine, but I decided to follow the message to upgrade to 25067. Since the upgrade, I have received the message "Controller "<name>" (HubitatController hubitat2) could not be loaded at startup. Its ID is not unique." MSR throws the message on every restart. Has anyone else encountered this problem?
I am running MSR on a Raspberry Pi4 connecting to two Hubitat units over an OpenVPN tunnel. One C8 and a C8 Pro. Both are up-to-date. It appears that despite the error message that MSR may be operating properly.

Multi-System Reactor 18 days ago
Global expressions not always evaluated
tunnusT

Similarly as for local expressions, global expressions evaluate and update fine when getEntity(...) structure is used. However, at least when certain functions are in use, expressions do not update.

Consider the following test case:

Screenshot 2025-03-13 at 16.29.42.png

Even though auto-evaluation is active, value does not change (it changes only if that expression is manually run). MSR restarts do not help.

Screenshot 2025-03-13 at 16.31.43.png

Note: Tested using build 25067 on Docker. I have also a PR open (but couldn't now get details or PR number as my Mantis account was somehow expired?).

Multi-System Reactor 20 days ago
[Solved] Local expression evaluation
V

Trying to understand what cause a local expresssion to be evaluated. I have read the manual but I am still not clear about it. Using the test rule below, I can see in the log that the rule is being automatically evaluated every time the temperature entity is changing. That is great...

What I am trying to understand is why the expression is not evaluated based on time as well since the "case" statement has time dependencies.

Any help would be appreciated

I have the following test rule:

eba6a3ea-ff61-4610-88c9-9b9864f11ff8-Screenshot 2025-01-21 095244.png

2d9c1ff5-7b73-4005-b324-9029c2709db9-Screenshot 2025-01-21 095302.png

Here is the expressioncode:

vFrom1 = "09:25:00", vFrom2 = "09:30:00", vFrom3 = "09:41:00", vTo = "10:55:00", # Get current time (format HH:MM:SS) vToDay = strftime("%H:%M:%S"), #Get current house temperature CurrentHouseTemp = getEntity( "hass>Thermostat2 " ).attributes.temperature_sensor.value, case when CurrentHouseTemp <= 19 and vToDay >= vFrom1 && vToDay <= vTo: "true1" # From1 when CurrentHouseTemp <= 20 and vToDay >= vFrom2 && vToDay <= vTo: "true2" # From2 when CurrentHouseTemp < 26  and vToDay >= vFrom3 && vToDay <= vTo: "true3" # From3 else "false" end
Multi-System Reactor Mar 12, 2025, 9:54 PM
[Solved] Runtime error when exiting global reaction that contains a group
S

I am getting a Runtime error on different browsers when I click exit when editing an existing or creating a new global reaction containing a group. If the global reaction does not have a group I don't get an error. I see a similar post on the forum about a Runtime Error when creating reactions but started a new thread as that appears to be solved.

The Runtime Error is different in the two browsers
Safari v18.3

@http://192.168.10.21:8111/reactor/en-US/lib/js/reaction-list.js:171:44 You may report this error, but do not screen shot it. Copy-paste the complete text. Remember to include a description of the operation you were performing in as much detail as possible. Report using the Reactor Bug Tracker (in your left navigation) or at the SmartHome Community.

Google Chrome 133.0.6943.142

TypeError: self.editor.isModified is not a function at HTMLButtonElement.<anonymous> (http://192.168.10.21:8111/reactor/en-US/lib/js/reaction-list.js:171:34) You may report this error, but do not screen shot it. Copy-paste the complete text. Remember to include a description of the operation you were performing in as much detail as possible. Report using the Reactor Bug Tracker (in your left navigation) or at the SmartHome Community.

Steps to reproduce:
Click the pencil to edit a global reaction with a group.
Click the Exit button.
Runtime error appears.
or
Click Create Reaction
Click Add Action
Select Group
Add Condition such as Entity Attribute.
Add an Action.
Click Save
Click Exit
Runtime error appears.

I don’t know how long the error has been there as I haven’t edited the global reaction in a long time.

Reactor (Multi-hub) latest-25060-f32eaa46
Docker
Mac OS: 15.3.1
Thanks

Multi-System Reactor Mar 10, 2025, 2:33 PM
Cannot delete Global Expressions
SnowmanS

I am trying to delete a global expression (gLightDelay) but for some strange reason, it comes back despite clicking the Delete this expression and Save Changes buttons.

I have not created a global expression for some times and just noticed this while doing some clean-up.

I have upgraded Reactor to 25067 from 25060 and the behaviour is still there. I have restarted Reactor (as well as restarting its container) and cleared the browser's cache several times without success.

Here's what the log shows.

[latest-25067]2025-03-08T23:50:22.690Z <wsapi:INFO> [WSAPI]wsapi#1 rpc_echo [Object]{ "comment": "UI activity" } [latest-25067]2025-03-08T23:50:26.254Z <GlobalExpression:NOTICE> Deleting global expression gLightDelay [latest-25067]2025-03-08T23:50:27.887Z <wsapi:INFO> [WSAPI]wsapi#1 rpc_echo [Object]{ "comment": "UI activity" }

Reactor latest-25067-62e21a2d
Docker on Synology NAS

Multi-System Reactor Mar 9, 2025, 2:32 AM
Local notification methods?
C

Morning, experts. Hard on learning about the internet check script in MSR tools, I was wondering what suggestions anyone has about a local (i.e. non-internet dependent) notification method.

This was prompted by yesterday's fun and games with my ISP.

I've got the script Cronned and working properly but short of flashing a light on and off, I'm struggling to think of a way of alerting me (ideally to my phone)

I guess I could set up a Discord server at home, but that feels like overkill for a rare occasion. Any other suggestions?

TIA

C

Multi-System Reactor Feb 14, 2025, 5:08 PM
Custom capabilities in MQTT templates
M

Hi,
I'm trying to integrate the sonos-mqtt (https://sonos2mqtt.svrooij.io/) with the MSR and it's coming along nicely so far.
But cannot wrap my head around how to define custom capabilities in MQTT templates. I need this for the TTS announcements and similarly for the notification sounds where I would pass the sound file as parameter.

So this is what I have in the local_mqtt_devices.yaml

capabilities: x_sonos_announcement: attributes: actions: speak: arguments: text: type: string volume: type: int delay: type: int

And this is the template:

templates: sonos-announcement: capabilities: - x_sonos_announcement actions: x_sonos_announcement: speak: topic: "sonos/cmd/speak" payload: expr: > { "text": parameters.text, "volume": parameters.volume, "delayMs": parameters.delay, "onlyWhenPlaying": false, "engine": "neural" } type: json

So the speak action should send something like this to topic sonos/cmd/speak

{ "text": "message goes here", "volume": 50, "delayMs": 100, "onlyWhenPlaying": false, "engine": "neural" }

At startup the MSR seems to be quite unhappy with my configuration:

reactor | [latest-25016]2025-02-09T08:19:59.029Z <MQTTController:WARN> MQTTController#mqtt entity Entity#mqtt>sonos-announcement unable to configure capabilities [Array][ "x_sonos_announcement" ] reactor | i18n: missing fi-FI language string: Configuration for {0:q} is incomplete because the following requested capabilities are undefined: {1} reactor | i18n: missing fi-FI language string: Configuration for {0:q} has unrecognized capability {1:q} in actions reactor | Trace: Configuration for {0:q} is incomplete because the following requested capabilities are undefined: {1} reactor | at _T (/opt/reactor/server/lib/i18n.js:611:28) reactor | at AlertManager.addAlert (/opt/reactor/server/lib/AlertManager.js:125:25) reactor | at MQTTController.sendWarning (/opt/reactor/server/lib/Controller.js:627:30) reactor | at MQTTController.start (/var/reactor/ext/MQTTController/MQTTController.js:268:26) reactor | at async Promise.allSettled (index 0) Configuration for "sonos-announcement" has unrecognized capability "x_sonos_announcement" in actions Controller: MQTTController#mqtt Last 10:21:37 AM Configuration for "sonos-announcement" is incomplete because the following requested capabilities are undefined: x_sonos_announcement Controller: MQTTController#mqtt Last 10:21:37 AM

This is probably a pretty stupid question and the approach may not even work at all, but maybe someone or @toggledbits for sure, could point me to the right direction.
Basically the idea is to be able to send TTS messages from reactions using entity actions. I've previously used HTTP requests to Sonos HTTP API (https://hub.docker.com/r/chrisns/docker-node-sonos-http-api/) for the same functionality, but since moving to sonos-mqtt, I need a way to send the TTS notifications using MQTTController. Along with the actual message, volume and delay must also be parameterizable.

br,
mgvra

MSR latest-25016-d47fea38 / MQTTController [0.2.24293]

Multi-System Reactor Feb 11, 2025, 1:28 PM
[SOLVED]Hass websocket falsely reporting ready on boot??
V

Hi, @toggledbits

I just noticed that following a reboot of my raspberry pi, some of the rules, that I was expecting to recover, are not catching up following a reboot. I have made a simple test rule (rule-m6rz6ol1) with only "after Date/time" as trigger and "turn on a lamp" as a set reaction. All my infrastructure is on the same board so Reactor, Hass, Zwavejs, ... are all rebooting.

Here is the sequence of the test case (All time converted to Zulu to match logs):

Rule "after Date/Time" set to 14:05:00z Shutdown on Raspberry Pi at 14:04:00z Power back up at 14:08:00z Rule overview shows true as of 14:08:14z waiting for 00:00:00 in GUI

From the log I can see that MSR is picking up the rule and knows that the state of the rule has changed from false to true and tries to send the update to HASS but failed with websocket error.

Here is what I see from the log:

14:04:04z shutdown complete 14:08:08z Power up 14:08:13.111z websocket connection 14:08:15:323z Reaction to the light failed, Websocket not opened After there is a series of websocket connection attempt until 14:08:51z where it seemed to be really ready.

Back in 2021 we had a discussion (https://smarthome.community/topic/700/solved-start-up?_=1738766986566) and you proposed to add a startup_delay:xxxx and startup_wait:xxxx parameter in the engine section of "reactor.yaml". When I try the startup_delay (this used to be a hard delay), the engine failed to start (I think). I then try the startup_wait:xxxx without any success. Since it wait for the connection status to be up to cancel the delay, it does not do anyting since Hass is reporting the socket up without really being up ( I think...).

Questions:

Did I figured it all wrong? should the startup_delay:xxxxx have worked? Any ideas?

Here is the log:

OK now I am stuck. I did add the log but when I submit the editor complained saying that I am limited to 32767 characters. The log from the shutdown to the time the websocket is stable is about 300000 character long. What are my options?

Multi-System Reactor Feb 10, 2025, 7:45 PM
[SOLVED]Logs permissions for Docker Install
V

Not a big issue simply a request if easily doable.

The MSR logs files inside the container are owned by root witch is fine however, the permissions are very restrictive. I do not know if there is something wrong with my installation but the logs permission are set to 222 (write only). Even if the docker volume is set for Read/Write the log files are retaining these values.

I go around the problem by doing a chmod 777 on all reactor logs but every time there is an MSR log rotation the permissions are set back to 222. So unless the permission are implemented in the container there is no permanent solution to this (that I know of).

I do not know much about Docker container so I do not know what is involved here.

Can the logfiles permission be simply chaged in the container to at least allow "other" read permission?

Could the MSR log rotation routine implement a chmod to set the permission?

Just a small anoyance

Thanks

Multi-System Reactor Feb 8, 2025, 6:05 PM

Pushover duplicate messages.

Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Multi-System Reactor
15 Posts 3 Posters 632 Views
  • Oldest to Newest
  • Newest to Oldest
  • Most Votes
Log in to reply
This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
  • T Offline
    T Offline
    Tom_D
    wrote on Jul 30, 2021, 8:09 PM last edited by Tom_D Jul 30, 2021, 4:12 PM
    #1

    I get duplicate Pushover messages.
    The Pushover section of the notification.yaml file is:

      # Pushover
  Pushover:
    profiles:
      default:
        # description - A friendly description of this profile (for menus)
        description: Default Profile
        #
        # user - (required) user key from Pushover. Refer to the Reactor docs for
        #        the Notify action for info on how to get your user key.
        user: "USERABC123"
        #
        # token - (required) token from Pushover site. Again, see the Reactor docs
        #         for info. This is the default token used for this profile if a
        #         token is not specified in the notification parameters.
        token: "TOKENABC123"
        #
        # default_device - (optional) name of the default device to receive not-
        #                  ifications. You can leave this blank, and the default
        #                  device will be whatever the Pushover API determines. If
        #                  set here, it's the default for this profile, when no
        #                  device is specified in the Notify action itself.
        default_device: "TomGS10"
        #
        # default_title - (optional) default notification title to use for this
        #                 profile. It will be used when no title is specified in
        #                 the Notify action. If no title is specified at all, the
        #                 system default title "Reactor" will be used.
        default_title: ""

    A sample rule that send the pushover message is:
    Reactor.png

    Reactor (Multi-system) 1.0.0-21200-16a604f

    latest-25082-3c348de6

    C 1 Reply Last reply Jul 30, 2021, 8:38 PM
    0
    • C Offline
      C Offline
      Crille
      replied to Tom_D on Jul 30, 2021, 8:38 PM last edited by
      #2

      @tom_d What is your trigger condition behind the three dots highlighted in yellow?

      1 Reply Last reply
      0
      • T Offline
        T Offline
        Tom_D
        wrote on Jul 30, 2021, 10:14 PM last edited by
        #3

        in this rule it is:

        Condition must be sustained for at least 2 seconds

        All my Pushover messages are duplicated, not just for this rule.

        latest-25082-3c348de6

        1 Reply Last reply
        0
        • C Offline
          C Offline
          Crille
          wrote on Jul 30, 2021, 10:26 PM last edited by
          #4

          Ah, ok. That sure is odd. I have several profiles and don’t use the default in any rule set. Never had any duplicates. Have you tried adding another profile to test with to rule out a bug using the default?

          1 Reply Last reply
          1
          • T Offline
            T Offline
            Tom_D
            wrote on Jul 31, 2021, 12:05 AM last edited by
            #5

            Wetting up different profiles may have fixed the problem. I'll post back here in a day or two.

            latest-25082-3c348de6

            1 Reply Last reply
            0
            • T Offline
              T Offline
              Tom_D
              wrote on Jul 31, 2021, 4:46 PM last edited by Tom_D Jul 31, 2021, 12:48 PM
              #6

              This problem seems resolved now. My new Pushover section of the notification.yaml file is:

                # Pushover
  Pushover:
    profiles:
      phonewin:
        # description - A friendly description of this profile (for menus)
        description: Phone and Windows
        #
        # user - (required) user key from Pushover. Refer to the Reactor docs for
        #        the Notify action for info on how to get your user key.
        user: "MyUserKey"
        #
        # token - (required) token from Pushover site. Again, see the Reactor docs
        #         for info. This is the default token used for this profile if a
        #         token is not specified in the notification parameters.
        token: "MyToken"
        #
        # default_device - (optional) name of the default device to receive not-
        #                  ifications. You can leave this blank, and the default
        #                  device will be whatever the Pushover API determines. If
        #                  set here, it's the default for this profile, when no
        #                  device is specified in the Notify action itself.
        default_device: "TomGS10,TomWin"
        #
        # default_title - (optional) default notification title to use for this
        #                 profile. It will be used when no title is specified in
        #                 the Notify action. If no title is specified at all, the
        #                 system default title "Reactor" will be used.
        default_title: ""
      phone:
        # description - A friendly description of this profile (for menus)
        description: Phone Only
        #
        # user - (required) user key from Pushover. Refer to the Reactor docs for
        #        the Notify action for info on how to get your user key.
        user: "MyUserKey"
        #
        # token - (required) token from Pushover site. Again, see the Reactor docs
        #         for info. This is the default token used for this profile if a
        #         token is not specified in the notification parameters.
        token: "MyToken"
        #
        # default_device - (optional) name of the default device to receive not-
        #                  ifications. You can leave this blank, and the default
        #                  device will be whatever the Pushover API determines. If
        #                  set here, it's the default for this profile, when no
        #                  device is specified in the Notify action itself.
        default_device: "TomGS10"
        #
        # default_title - (optional) default notification title to use for this
        #                 profile. It will be used when no title is specified in
        #                 the Notify action. If no title is specified at all, the
        #                 system default title "Reactor" will be used.
        default_title: ""
      windows:
        # description - A friendly description of this profile (for menus)
        description: Windows Only
        #
        # user - (required) user key from Pushover. Refer to the Reactor docs for
        #        the Notify action for info on how to get your user key.
        user: "MyUserKey"
        #
        # token - (required) token from Pushover site. Again, see the Reactor docs
        #         for info. This is the default token used for this profile if a
        #         token is not specified in the notification parameters.
        token: "MyToken"
        #
        # default_device - (optional) name of the default device to receive not-
        #                  ifications. You can leave this blank, and the default
        #                  device will be whatever the Pushover API determines. If
        #                  set here, it's the default for this profile, when no
        #                  device is specified in the Notify action itself.
        default_device: "TomWin"
        #
        # default_title - (optional) default notification title to use for this
        #                 profile. It will be used when no title is specified in
        #                 the Notify action. If no title is specified at all, the
        #                 system default title "Reactor" will be used.
        default_title: ""

              latest-25082-3c348de6

              C 1 Reply Last reply Aug 2, 2021, 3:09 PM
              1
              • C Offline
                C Offline
                Crille
                replied to Tom_D on Aug 2, 2021, 3:09 PM last edited by
                #7

                @toggledbits Today I created a rule with default profile to see if I could reproduce @tom_d 's issue. I was not able to so I deleted the rule.
                Later this evening I got duplicate messages from one of my unedited previously working notifications. My logs have already rotated so I can't find any info there. Have you noticed this issue yourself? I don't know if I have enough info for a PR so just poking this thread again.

                1 Reply Last reply
                0
                • C Offline
                  C Offline
                  Crille
                  wrote on Aug 3, 2021, 10:11 AM last edited by Crille Aug 3, 2021, 10:29 AM
                  #8

                  It's really an intermittent problem. All my notifications were duplicated until I today switched to run MSR as systemd. I did not edit any rules/reactions or the notification.yaml and now I only get one per rule as expected. Could be the restart itself that solved it...

                  1 Reply Last reply
                  0
                  • T Offline
                    T Offline
                    toggledbits
                    wrote on Aug 3, 2021, 11:33 AM last edited by
                    #9

                    Is anybody looking at the logs? You'll be able to see the reactions there, and confirm, I'm sure, that the notification action is occurring only one per run of the reaction. The action will only make one call to the Pushover API; there is no retry or attempt at error recovery if the API request fails. For more detail, set the NotifyPushover log level to 5 or 6 (5 would be sufficient to see and count the actual API calls to Pushover). Are you sure your reaction not running multiple times due to the controlling logic?

                    It's also the case that Pushover has, in the past, had issues on Android specifically with duplicate messages due to Google's/Andoid's notification services. It could be a bug in their API or their app.

                    I myself have never seen duplicate messages (and I'm on Android).

                    Author of Multi-system Reactor and Reactor, DelayLight, Switchboard, and about a dozen other plugins that run on Vera and openLuup.

                    C 1 Reply Last reply Aug 3, 2021, 2:28 PM
                    0
                    • C Offline
                      C Offline
                      Crille
                      replied to toggledbits on Aug 3, 2021, 2:28 PM last edited by Crille Aug 3, 2021, 10:30 AM
                      #10

                      @toggledbits My logs rotate to quick, I have about 7 min to grab them and notifications are sent when I'm not at my computer, so I have not found any hints there yet. Tried the console.log but it was too big to handle.
                      I will try to catch it if it happens again.
                      I'm almost certain the reactions are not running multiple times due to rather simple logic, will investigate logs if I catch it at the right time though.
                      I'm on iPhone and suspecting it's generated at Pushover too but none of my other, non MSR calls, to their API has ever produced duplicates and it started when I tried to reproduce it and then suddenly vanished after a restart.

                      Could MSR been running multiple instances when manually started by app.sh?

                      Otherwise, lets leave it until I or anyone else find something of value to troubleshoot as it's working perfect again now.

                      T 1 Reply Last reply Aug 3, 2021, 3:33 PM
                      0
                      • T Offline
                        T Offline
                        toggledbits
                        wrote on Aug 3, 2021, 3:15 PM last edited by toggledbits Aug 3, 2021, 11:19 AM
                        #11

                        If your logs are rotating that quickly, can you post your logging.yaml and let's see if something has been left too high from other threads. Unless you are looking for something, everything except Engine should be at level 4; Engineis best left at 5 for the moment while looking at this. The default log level should never ever be set to anything higher than 4.

                        And as I said, add NotifyPushover at level 5 or 6, but that's going to be so low traffic it should not matter.

                        FYI, I have my logs set to rotate at 8MB (the default is 2MB), on a very busy system running my house Vera, Hass, Hubitat, and eZLO, and my log rotates about once every 4 days.

                        Author of Multi-system Reactor and Reactor, DelayLight, Switchboard, and about a dozen other plugins that run on Vera and openLuup.

                        C 1 Reply Last reply Aug 3, 2021, 3:55 PM
                        0
                        • T Offline
                          T Offline
                          toggledbits
                          replied to Crille on Aug 3, 2021, 3:33 PM last edited by
                          #12

                          @crille said in Pushover duplicate messages.:

                          Could MSR been running multiple instances when manually started by app.sh?

                          pgrep -a node will answer this question.

                          Author of Multi-system Reactor and Reactor, DelayLight, Switchboard, and about a dozen other plugins that run on Vera and openLuup.

                          1 Reply Last reply
                          0
                          • C Offline
                            C Offline
                            Crille
                            replied to toggledbits on Aug 3, 2021, 3:55 PM last edited by
                            #13

                            @toggledbits Ok, since I switched to systemd and rebooted the server today, unfortunately I can't see if it was running multiple instances yesterday. I now only see one.

                            I lowered EzloController from 7 to 4 yesterday and it's a bit better now, this is my current config:

                            logging:
  default:
    level: 4
    streams:
      - type: console
        level: 6
      - type: file
        name: "reactor.log"
        maxsize: 2  # megabytes
        keep: 5     # copies of old logs
  app:
    level: 4
  httpapi:
    level: 4
  httpproxy:
    level: 4
  wsapi:
    level: 4
  Structure:
    level: 4
  Controller:
    level: 4
  OWMWeatherController:
    level: 4
  VeraController:
    level: 4
  HubitatController:
    level: 4
  HassController:
    level: 4
  Rule:
    level: 5
  Engine:
    level: 5
  EzloController:
    level: 4

                            So I should lower everything else except Engine to 4 as well? The log is very chatty right now in my opinion.
                            I will add NotifyPushover if the issue comes back but I'm suspecting it was multiple instances causing it.

                            1 Reply Last reply
                            0
                            • T Offline
                              T Offline
                              toggledbits
                              wrote on Aug 3, 2021, 3:58 PM last edited by
                              #14

                              Yes, set Rule down to 4, leave Engine at 5, and add NotifyPushover at 5 or 6.

                              Author of Multi-system Reactor and Reactor, DelayLight, Switchboard, and about a dozen other plugins that run on Vera and openLuup.

                              1 Reply Last reply
                              1
                              • C Offline
                                C Offline
                                Crille
                                wrote on Aug 3, 2021, 4:02 PM last edited by Crille Aug 3, 2021, 12:17 PM
                                #15

                                Ok, done. Much better, thank you!

                                1 Reply Last reply
                                0
                                • T toggledbits locked this topic on Dec 31, 2021, 9:47 PM

                                8/15

                                Aug 3, 2021, 10:11 AM

                                Recent Topics

                                • Organizing/ structuring rule sets and rules
                                  R
                                  RHCPNG
                                  about 4 hours ago
                                  0
                                  1
                                  6
                                • Remote access of Zwave stick from Z-wave server
                                  C
                                  CatmanV2
                                  2 days ago
                                  0
                                  2
                                  28
                                • Moving MSR from a QNAP container to RP 5 - some issues
                                  G
                                  gwp1
                                  3 days ago
                                  0
                                  5
                                  109
                                • Widget deletion does not work and landing page (status) is empy
                                  G
                                  gwp1
                                  3 days ago
                                  0
                                  4
                                  94
                                • Need help reducing false positive notifications
                                  T
                                  tamorgen
                                  4 days ago
                                  0
                                  7
                                  192
                                • Reactor (Multi-System/Multi-Hub) Announcements
                                  T
                                  toggledbits
                                  5 days ago
                                  5
                                  120
                                  17.3k
                                • Deleting widgets
                                  T
                                  toggledbits
                                  5 days ago
                                  0
                                  4
                                  266
                                • MQTT configuration question
                                  tunnusT
                                  tunnus
                                  9 days ago
                                  0
                                  11
                                  260
                                • System Configuration Check - time is offset
                                  G
                                  gwp1
                                  10 days ago
                                  0
                                  8
                                  245
                                • Programmatically capture HTTP Request action status code or error
                                  therealdbT
                                  therealdb
                                  12 days ago
                                  0
                                  3
                                  194
                                • ZwaveJSUI - RGBWW BULB - Warm/Cold White interfered with RGB settings - Bulb doesn't change color if in WarmWhite state.
                                  T
                                  toggledbits
                                  13 days ago
                                  0
                                  9
                                  302
                                Powered by NodeBB | Contributors
                                Hosted freely by 10RUPTiV - Solutions Technologiques | Contact us
                                • Login
                                • Don't have an account? Register
                                • Login or register to search.
                                8 out of 15
                                • First post
                                  8/15
                                  Last post
                                0
                                • Categories
                                • Recent
                                • Tags
                                • Popular
                                • Unsolved