This trigger no longer working - complaining about the operator needing changing

[Andr]

So, first steps taken - Logging events from HomeAssistant.

First enable logging by adding marked line in reactor\config\reactor.yaml
And of course edit false to TRUE when for logging to start, I am done with that part now

A little tip.
I had my file explorer in reactor\logs folder
So to don't get to much data in the hass_events.log i made a copy of the file as soon I had send the different commands for one of the buttons.
So now i have one log file for everyone of my six buttons, and every button handle 1x, 2x, 3x click + hold so it feels some what readable.

[Andr]

I am reading about MSR abilities, and wonder which one is best in my scenario.

Standard Capabilities - Reactor - Multi-Hub Automation

I am thinking about "button" as it should be only one entity for each button on the remote, if I have got it right?

Any thoughts?

button

Used when the device implements the behavior of a pressable button.

Attributes:

state — (string) last button state: single (pressed once), double (double-press), triple (triple-press), 4 (four-press), 5 (five-press), hold, release, long, unknown. Not all Controller instances will (or are required to) implement all values; this is dependent on the capabilities of the underlying hub and the device itself.

[toggledbits]

@andr great choice!

[Andr]

===group

===So, a little report of a night of testing what does not work.

Read @toggledbits tips above together with the manual about Capabilites and put this in my reactor.yaml:

    config:
      source: ':-D'
      access_token: ':-)'
      log_events: false
          # Additions to config section for Lukas Fibaro Keyfob:
      event_targets:    # this section starts the event-receiving entities
        "Keyfob_fyrkant":      # Assign an ID to your entity; each entity must have a unique ID
          name: Lukas Keyfob Fyrkant   # This is optional but recommended, so you have a friendly name
          capabilities: ['button'] # define an array of capabilities to be modified by the event 
           attributes:
             state:
               type: string
               values:
                 - 'single'
                 - 'double'
                 - 'triple'
                 - 'hold'
                 - 'release'
             since:
               type: int, timestamp
          events:  # define an array of events that modify capability attributes on the entity
          - event:  # start of an event; each element of the events array begins this way
              event_type: zwave_js_value_notification
              data:  # optional section, if further matching to the event data is required
                property: "Scene 001" # Square button
                value: "KeyPressed"   # Square button event
            response:  # begin the (required) response section for handling the event
              "button.state":  # an attribute that the event modifies.
                expr: "single"   # expression to get attribute value from event data
                from: "event.data.property.value"  # dot-reference expression to pull value from event message
                map:                    # optional, map to modify value
                  string: 'single'   # if value is value_in, it is mapped to new_value 
              # repeat "capability.attribute" section for all attributes modified by the event
      #    - event:  # start of next event for this entity, same form as above

This did not work at all, Reactor would not even start
Tinkered with a bit, but no luck.
Anyone see if it is something simple to fix or is this beyond saving?

Testing something simpler, just to see that I can create some kind of Hass Entity, I copied @toggledbits motion_sensor example above and made some adjustments.

      event_targets:
        "knapp_fyrkant":
          capabilities: ['binary_sensor']
          primary_attribute: binary_sensor.state
          events:
            - event:
                event_type: zwave_js_value_notification
                data:
                  property: "Scene 001"
                  value: "KeyPressed"
              response:
                "binary_sensor.state":
                  from: "event.data.property.value"
                  map:
                    KeyPressed: true

A tiny, little bit, closer... Reactor starts again and I got myself a fresh new binary sensor "knapp_fyrkant"
But I am guessing something is wrong in data and/or response section because the "sensor" doesn't changes to true.

I dont think I really follow how event data and response from relate. I need to sleep on this

from: "event.data.payload.action"

Here is info from hass event log, for pressing the Square button 1x and 2x.

2022 - 06 - 29 T21: 15: 44.500 Z zwave_js_value_notification {
	"id": 1656536987817,
	"type": "event",
	"event": {
		"event_type": "zwave_js_value_notification",
		"data": {
			"domain": "zwave_js",
			"node_id": 15,
			"home_id": 3523230191,
			"endpoint": 0,
			"device_id": "4cfedde34f701262785f27ac571a7f80",
			"command_class": 91,
			"command_class_name": "Central Scene",
			"label": "Scene 001",
			"property": "scene",
			"property_name": "scene",
			"property_key": "001",
			"property_key_name": "001",
			"value": "KeyPressed",
			"value_raw": 0
		},
		"origin": "LOCAL",
		"time_fired": "2022-06-29T21:15:43.082064+00:00",
		"context": {
			"id": "01G6RN3S3ASSBZ33RYPHND6QG8",
			"parent_id": null,
			"user_id": null
		}
	}
}
2022 - 06 - 29 T21: 15: 50.890 Z zwave_js_value_notification {
	"id": 1656536987817,
	"type": "event",
	"event": {
		"event_type": "zwave_js_value_notification",
		"data": {
			"domain": "zwave_js",
			"node_id": 15,
			"home_id": 3523230191,
			"endpoint": 0,
			"device_id": "4cfedde34f701262785f27ac571a7f80",
			"command_class": 91,
			"command_class_name": "Central Scene",
			"label": "Scene 001",
			"property": "scene",
			"property_name": "scene",
			"property_key": "001",
			"property_key_name": "001",
			"value": "KeyPressed2x",
			"value_raw": 3
		},
		"origin": "LOCAL",
		"time_fired": "2022-06-29T21:15:49.475286+00:00",
		"context": {
			"id": "01G6RN3ZB3BYRPDZMM9S6CMRZB",
			"parent_id": null,
			"user_id": null
		}
	}
}

Just noticed that I have mixed up "property" with "label" so I think I start there tomorrow.
Good night!

[toggledbits]

This did not work at all, Reactor would not even start

Not surprised it wouldn't start... it's not properly formatted. Two errors: the attributes line is incorrectly indented (and therefore so is everything underneath it). Second issue, it shouldn't even be there. If it was properly indented, it would be ignored, because the code isn't looking for it. The definition of the button capability is already determined by system files; you don't need to repeat it here.

As for the rest of it, the - event is also not properly indented, although this may not make it choke.

Your property value in the event section won't match anything. That value doesn't appear in the example data you posted. It does match label, however, but I don't recommend using that. Change the property value to scene and add property_key with value 001. You probably also want to match the specific device, so that if you have more than one of these, these rules apply only to this one; do this by matching node_id.

Your response has a few issues. Traversing your sample data, the action field is event.data.value not event.data.property.value. The expr line shouldn't be there, since you're using map to remap the string values grabbed by from. The word string in the map data should be the word KeyPressed (an actual string you are looking for) with the value single (the string you want it to be, which matches the definition of the button.state attribute). If there are other possible strings that map to double, triple, hold and release, those should be added to the map; since you show in your sample data a 2x press, I added that (see below).

Then, to make sure button.since is correctly updated (modified for each event), you need to specify it as an attribute to be updated as part of the event response, and in this case we will use an expression to set it to the current time.

Correcting all that, I give you this:

      event_targets:    # this section starts the event-receiving entities
        "Keyfob_fyrkant":      # Assign an ID to your entity; each entity must have a unique ID
          name: Lukas Keyfob Fyrkant   # This is optional but recommended, so you have a friendly name
          capabilities: ['button']  # define an array of capabilities to be modified by the event 
          events:  # define an array of events that modify capability attributes on the entity
            - event:  # start of an event; each element of the events array begins this way
                event_type: zwave_js_value_notification
                data:  # optional section, if further matching to the event data is required
                  node_id: 15
                  property: "scene" # Square button
                  property_key: "001"
              response:  # begin the (required) response section for handling the event
                "button.state":  # an attribute that the event modifies.
                  from: "event.data.value"  # dot-reference expression to pull value from event message
                  map:                    # optional, map to modify value
                    KeyPressed: 'single'   # if value is value_in, it is mapped to new_value
                    KeyPressed2x: 'double'
                  map_unmatched: 'unknown'
                "button.since":
                  expr: "time()"

I highly recommend using a syntax-highlighting YAML editor. Check out https://onlineyamltools.com/edit-yaml

[Andr]

Many thanks!
will be digging in to this later tonight again.

A few follow up questions to check that I understand things correctly.

capabilities: ['button']

In frase above, somewhere in MSR code, the word 'button' is equal to what I tried to specify with this section and that why that was unnecessary?
```
attributes:

         state:

           type: string

           values:

             - 'single'

             - 'double'

             - 'triple'

             - 'hold'

             - 'release'

         since:

           type: int, timestamp

About how to fill the 'form' row, in your example you use

from: "event.data.payload.action"

And I assume that this comes from this marked words? 
![b80fc4eb-315e-4ba0-af3b-ffe5f470ebc6-image.png](/assets/uploads/files/1656701263037-b80fc4eb-315e-4ba0-af3b-ffe5f470ebc6-image.png) 

I starting to think that yaml file should be read somewhat like a folder tree, would that make sense?
So, in your example, if the 'start action' was like a .bat-file the way to think about the Form row the adress would be **event\data\payload\action**
Please say I am on the right track 😂🙏

[Andr]

Sorry for the messy post above, writing from my phone

[toggledbits]

Yeah, you need to fix it. It should not be left like this, as the discussion may be read by others in future, and I can't follow it (also on my phone), and likely nobody would bother

From what I can see, I don't know why you're stuck on using payload in your from value, that word/key does not appear in your event data.

[Andr]

Ok, for some reason i can't make the mess go away in earlier post, so double post...

Many thanks!
will be digging in to this later tonight again.

A few follow up questions to check that I understand things correctly.

capabilities: ['button']

In frase above, somewhere in MSR code, the word 'button' is equal to what I tried to specify with this section and that why that was unnecessary?

attributes:

            state:

              type: string

              values:

                - 'single'

                - 'double'

                - 'triple'

                - 'hold'

                - 'release'

            since:

              type: int, timestamp

About how to fill the 'form' row, in your example you use

from: "event.data.payload.action"

And I assume that this comes from this marked words?

I starting to think that yaml file should be read somewhat like a folder tree, would that make sense?
So, in your example, if the 'start action' was like a .bat-file the way to think about the Form row the adress would be event\data\payload\action
Please say I am on the right track

[Andr]

Ok, some progress thanks to @toggledbits of course.

Copied in his code in reactor.yaml and that worked fine of course. Also added a line for 3x click and that worked also.

event_targets:    # this section starts the event-receiving entities
        "Keyfob_fyrkant":      # Assign an ID to your entity; each entity must have a unique ID
          name: Lukas Keyfob Fyrkant   # This is optional but recommended, so you have a friendly name
          capabilities: ['button']  # define an array of capabilities to be modified by the event 
          events:  # define an array of events that modify capability attributes on the entity
            - event:  # start of an event; each element of the events array begins this way
                event_type: zwave_js_value_notification
                data:  # optional section, if further matching to the event data is required
                  node_id: 15
                  property: "scene" # Square button
                  property_key: "001"
              response:  # begin the (required) response section for handling the event
                "button.state":  # an attribute that the event modifies.
                  from: "event.data.value"  # dot-reference expression to pull value from event message
                  map:                    # optional, map to modify value
                    KeyPressed: 'single'   # if value is value_in, it is mapped to new_value
                    KeyPressed2x: 'double'
                    KeyPressed3x: 'tripple'

But, still, I can't for some reason really understand the code and how different parts relate to each other.

In 'event data' I was expecting to fill out in the 'label' field from hass_event log because that is an uniq value for each one of the six buttons, and then the 'value' field that identifies the number of keypresses on this specific button.
In my mind that would give a uniq combination for MSR to identify.
I did (with very low hopes) tried it also

event_targets:    # this section starts the event-receiving entities
        "Keyfob_fyrkant":      # Assign an ID to your entity; each entity must have a unique ID
          name: Lukas Keyfob Fyrkant   # This is optional but recommended, so you have a friendly name
          capabilities: ['button']  # define an array of capabilities to be modified by the event 
          events:  # define an array of events that modify capability attributes on the entity
            - event:  # start of an event; each element of the events array begins this way
                event_type: zwave_js_value_notification
                data:  # optional section, if further matching to the event data is required
                  node_id: 15
                  label: "Scene 001" # Square button
                  value: "KeyPressed"
                  value: "KeyPressed2x"
                  value: "KeyPressed3x"
              response:  # begin the (required) response section for handling the event
                "button.state":  # an attribute that the event modifies.
                  from: "event.data.value"  # dot-reference expression to pull value from event message
                  map:                    # optional, map to modify value
                    KeyPressed: 'single'   # if value is value_in, it is mapped to new_value
                    KeyPressed2x: 'double'
                    KeyPressed3x: 'tripple'

and of course:
Reactor did not start.

I would really like to get a grip why this is what is needed in event data

                  property: "scene" # Square button
                  property_key: "001"

Meanwhile, as @toggledbits code of course worked I did the simplest rule with an action, toggle a lamp on off.

Here I expected (or hoped) to find triggers for every combination of button presses.
For now Square: 1x, 2x, 3x
But I guess I need to set the 'button.state' to 'contains' 'single' 'double' etc.
But whatever event state MSR caught, it doesn't resest.
When MSR start the value is NULL, but after a click it holds that value, for example 'single', and I expect it to reset immediately after the 'single' event have passed by.

So, this is it for today. It is friday night and I am happy to say that I think my wife misses me
Have a great weekend everyone.

[toggledbits]

But, still, I can't for some reason really understand the code and how different parts relate to each other.

The event section is a filter to look for a specific event. In your version, you have multiple value keys, which is not allowed. Also, you don't want to filter by value, just accept them all and let the response section deal with them. I recommended against using label because it's changeable in ZWave, whereas the property and property_key values are defined by the device and will not change.

So again, the event section is the filter that determines what incoming event will match, and what will not.

Once an event matches, the response section determines what to do with it. Each component of the response section is an attribute of an assigned capability and the instructions to set it. In the case of button.state, my version says grab the value from event.data.value, and then, map that value from the device's string to one of Reactor's accepted capability/attribute value. Setting button.since completes the "contract" of the button capability (i.e. makes it work like similar uses of button in other devices and related to other controllers). I'm not sure I can explain it more simply than that.

It's really just a "if you find this... do this" configuration. The effect is that if a matching button event is detected by the event section, the response section will interpet the value and map it to a Reactor-compatible value to place on the entity attribute button.state, and also update the button.since timestamp. Thus the since timestamp changes every time a button press event is received, but state may not change, because it's possible to press a button once, wait 15 seconds, and press the same button again, which will result in the value single being persistent on the state attribute and not changing. So to detect an event, you have to check both state and since (and this is consistent with all button behavior in Reactor).

To test button state in a rule, you test button.state for what you want in that rule (equals single, double, triple), and you AND that test with a button.since changes (from any to any). That will send a very short pulse when a matching button press occurs. While testing, to make sure you can see it, add a "sustained for" delay on the changes condition of a few seconds (keep it short), and you'll more easily see what's going on in the status view. Make sure to remove the delay when you're done playing (keeping it will dampen response to buttons when, for example, a single press is done repeatedly within the delay period).

Example here: https://smarthome.community/assets/uploads/files/1646184651741-cbff18f3-ce2d-4ecd-ae65-2554f77a4a80-image.png

[Andr]

@toggledbits

Ok, I understood it at first that I needed to specify more stuff in the event section, like 'value' so it then could be mapped to right command, otherwise it would not be known.

But nodeid, property and property key is just to filter out right device, all the other data is still there?
And in that case, I guess that it would work to skip event data and just mapping commands to MSR functions? (Of course nothing else can send 'Keypressed' command because that would be messy)

[toggledbits]

@andr said in Adding remotes, scene controllers as entities to MSR:

But nodeid, property and property key is just to filter out right device, all the other data is still there?

That's right. The event section only filters using the data; it does not modify the data or transform it in any way. Whatever is received in the event structure stays as received.

@andr said in Adding remotes, scene controllers as entities to MSR:

And in that case, I guess that it would work to skip event data and just mapping commands to MSR functions?

I'm not sure what you mean by this. I don't think you want to skip anything. You should filter the incoming events, to make sure that you are handling the right events from the right device. So you need to be specific in the event filter to both the event type and the sending device.

[Andr]

@toggledbits said in Adding remotes, scene controllers as entities to MSR:

||@andr said in Adding remotes, scene controllers as entities to MSR:

And in that case, I guess that it would work to skip event data and just mapping commands to MSR functions?||

I'm not sure what you mean by this. I don't think you want to skip anything. You should filter the incoming events, to make sure that you are handling the right events from the right device. So you need to be specific in the event filter to both the event type and the sending device.

That was just me trying to understand how stuff is related, not something I would try out.
For example, in my system there is only one device that are sending "Keypressed3x" and that can not be mixed up with anything else. In that case if I had such uniq string to map to MSR command 'triple' I could skip the filtering in event section?

Again, this is just for my own curiosa trying to learn something new.

[Andr]

Anyway, some kinds of sucess the last nights

All buttons are configured and seems to work so far.

The final reactor.yaml looks like this (just showing the first two buttons as it is just the entity name and 'property key' that differ )

event_targets:    # this section starts the event-receiving entities
        "Keyfob_Fyrkant":      # Assign an ID to your entity; each entity must have a unique ID
          name: Lukas Keyfob Fyrkant   # This is optional but recommended, so you have a friendly name
          capabilities: ['button']  # define an array of capabilities to be modified by the event 
          events:  # define an array of events that modify capability attributes on the entity
            - event:  # start of an event; each element of the events array begins this way
                event_type: zwave_js_value_notification
                data:  # optional section, if further matching to the event data is required
                  node_id: 15
                  property: "scene" # Square button
                  property_key: "001"
              response:  # begin the (required) response section for handling the event
                "button.state":  # an attribute that the event modifies.
                  from: "event.data.value"  # dot-reference expression to pull value from event message
                  map:                    # optional, map to modify value
                    KeyPressed: 'single'   # if value is value_in, it is mapped to new_value
                    KeyPressed2x: 'double'
                    KeyPressed3x: 'tripple'
                    KeyHeldDown: 'hold'
                    KeyReleased: 'release'
                "button.since":  # an attribute that the event modifies.
                  from: "event.context.id"  # dot-reference expression to pull value from event message
        "Keyfob_Ring":      # Assign an ID to your entity; each entity must have a unique ID
          name: Lukas Keyfob Ring   # This is optional but recommended, so you have a friendly name
          capabilities: ['button']  # define an array of capabilities to be modified by the event 
          events:  # define an array of events that modify capability attributes on the entity
            - event:  # start of an event; each element of the events array begins this way
                event_type: zwave_js_value_notification
                data:  # optional section, if further matching to the event data is required
                  node_id: 15
                  property: "scene" # Circle button
                  property_key: "002"
              response:  # begin the (required) response section for handling the event
                "button.state":  # an attribute that the event modifies.
                  from: "event.data.value"  # dot-reference expression to pull value from event message
                  map:                    # optional, map to modify value
                    KeyPressed: 'single'   # if value is value_in, it is mapped to new_value
                    KeyPressed2x: 'double'
                    KeyPressed3x: 'triple'
                    KeyHeldDown: 'hold'
                    KeyReleased: 'release'
                "button.since":  # an attribute that the event modifies.
                  from: "event.context.id"  # dot-reference expression to pull value from event message

A thought that crossed my mind recently, to maybe expand the functions of this little remote in the future.
Fibaro have built in a possibilty for 6 extra scenes that activates after a sequence of button presses I specify. I have not activated this yet as I don't think I really need it, but what I realised is that it probably quite easy to add a lot of differnt button sequences in MSR as long or short that I want?

Next part is to get some rules and actions set-up that can use the remote.

[Andr]

Seems to work like a charm

Started out with a few rules to let him control a Sonos in his room.
This one is for starting his favorite playlist, when it not is bedtime and that playlist isn't already playing.

[christian_fabre]

Thanks ...
I followed this post and managed to successfully use my HANK SCN04 remote with Reactor and Home Assistant.

[Andr]

@christian_fabre
Happy to hear that it come to use (and that myself learned a few things on the way)

[toggledbits]

@andr said in Adding remotes, scene controllers as entities to MSR:

In that case if I had such uniq string to map to MSR command 'triple' I could skip the filtering in event section?

No. You must filter. If you don't, every incoming event then causes the response section to act and will likely cause spurious changes of the entity data.

[apocalypsehobby]

@christian_fabre said in Adding remotes, scene controllers as entities to MSR:

Thanks ...
I followed this post and managed to successfully use my HANK SCN04 remote with Reactor and Home Assistant.

@christian_fabre Do you mind sharing the code you used? I have two of the HANK SCN04 as well, and am trying to do the same thing